Specific Emitter Identification (SEI) is advantageous for its ability to passively identify emitters by exploiting distinct, unique, and organic features unintentionally imparted upon every signal during formation and transmission. These features are attributed to the slight variations and imperfections that exist in the Radio Frequency (RF) front end, thus SEI is being proposed as a physical layer security technique. The majority of SEI work assumes the targeted emitter is a passive source with immutable and difficult-to-mimic signal features. However, Software-Defined Radio (SDR) proliferation and Deep Learning (DL) advancements require a reassessment of these assumptions, because DL can learn SEI features directly from an emitter’s signals and SDR enables signal manipulation. This paper investigates a strong adversary that uses SDR and DL to mimic an authorized emitter’s signal features to circumvent SEI-based identity verification. The investigation considers three SEI mimicry approaches, two different SDR platforms, the presence or lack of signal energy as well as a "decoy" emitter. The results show that "off-the-shelf" DL achieves effective SEI mimicry. Additionally, SDR constraints impact SEI mimicry effectiveness and suggest an adversary’s minimum requirements. Future SEI research must consider adversaries capable of mimicking another emitter’s SEI features or manipulating their own.